Sell handmade or vintage goods on Etsy under an anonymous LLC. Personal address never appears on shipping labels or buyer chats.
By Shafwan Ahmed, Operations & Fulfillment Lead, Anonymousllc.co
Wyoming anonymous LLC, disregarded entity. The LLC owns the Etsy shop, the EIN, and the business bank account. Etsy payouts route to the LLC. Etsy Payments handles sales tax collection in most US states automatically. The Wyoming registered agent address replaces your home on every public record.
Etsy buyers receive your shipping return address on every order. Aggrieved buyers post Yelp reviews tied to your legal name. An anonymous LLC means the return address is the Wyoming RA, the legal seller is the LLC, and your home address never appears in the order chain.
Lowest annual cost ($60). Best banking acceptance for Etsy sellers. Wyoming RA address is your return address - buyers never see your home.
| State | Price | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Wyoming (recommended) | $397 | Best balance of cost, anonymity, banking acceptance. |
| New Mexico | $347 | Cheapest. No annual report. Banking is harder. |
Every Etsy order ships with a return address, and an anonymous LLC lets that address be the Wyoming registered agent instead of your home. The legal seller becomes the LLC, not you. Etsy prints the return address you set as your default shipping origin on every package, and buyers see it the moment a parcel arrives. Aggrieved buyers post reviews and complaints tied to whatever name and address they can find. When you form a Wyoming LLC, your name never appears on the Articles of Organization, the registered agent address replaces your home, and you set that same registered-agent address as your Etsy return address under Settings then Shipping. Buyers see the LLC name and a business address, and passive searches of state records return the registered agent rather than you.
Form the LLC, obtain the EIN, then switch your Etsy shop to a business account, submit a W-9 under the LLC EIN, and point Etsy Payments at the LLC's business bank account. Start in Etsy's Finances and Legal and taxpayer settings, where you replace your personal SSN with the LLC EIN on the W-9. That change moves your year-end 1099-K to the LLC rather than your name. In Etsy Payments, update the deposit account to the LLC's Mercury or Relay account, which opens about 8-10 days after the EIN. Your listings, reviews, and shop name carry over untouched. Set the registered-agent address as your default return address in the same session so new orders ship from the entity address.
Etsy handles it. As a marketplace facilitator, Etsy Payments calculates, collects, and remits sales tax in the 47 states plus DC that require it, so an Etsy-only seller manages no sales-tax filings. Marketplace facilitator laws shift the sales-tax duty from the individual seller to the platform for sales made through that platform. Etsy applies the correct rate at checkout and remits to each state, and the LLC structure does not change this. The duty returns to you only for sales made outside Etsy - a Shopify store, a WooCommerce site, or in-person markets - where you would register in nexus states yourself. Running every channel through the one LLC and EIN keeps that bookkeeping in a single place.
Wyoming at $397 is the recommended choice: the best banking acceptance for Etsy Payments payouts and a low $60 annual report. New Mexico at $347 is cheaper with no annual report but harder banking. Etsy Payments deposits to a real business bank account, and Mercury and Relay approve Wyoming LLCs more readily than New Mexico ones, which is why Wyoming leads for marketplace sellers. Wyoming costs $397 all-in ($297 service plus $100 state) and keeps a $60 minimum annual report due in your formation-anniversary month. New Mexico costs $347 all-in ($297 plus $50 state) and requires no annual report and no annual fee, but a New Mexico payout account is tougher to secure. For a shop whose income depends on reliable Etsy deposits, Wyoming banking wins the tradeoff.
Yes. Etsy issues a 1099-K once you cross the federal reporting threshold - $5,000 for 2024 - and submitting a W-9 under the LLC EIN moves that form to the entity instead of your personal SSN. A 1099-K reports your gross Etsy Payments volume to the IRS. Filed under a personal SSN, it ties your name to the shop in IRS records and on any document a client or partner requests. Once the LLC EIN sits on your Etsy taxpayer profile, the 1099-K carries the LLC name and EIN, and the income flows onto the LLC's return. For a single-member Wyoming LLC that stays a disregarded entity, the numbers still land on your personal Schedule C, but the reporting trail runs through the entity.
WhatsApp the founder. 5-minute intake, 5-10 day turnaround.
WhatsApp the founder